Operating system and software
The iPhone 6 Plus
comes out of the box running iOS 8 but automatically updates to the
latest iOS 8.1 version. Similarly, the Nexus 6 comes running Google's
Android 5.0 operating system, but has an update to the latest 5.1
version available.
In past reviews we've found iOS slightly more future proof than
Android. This is largely down to Apple's closed management of the OS.
Apple blocks developers making changes to the software. This means
that Apple can deploy updates much more quickly than Google, as Android
handsets usually feature custom skins and software additions.
However, this problem isn't present on the Nexus 6, which features a completely unskinned version of Lollipop.
Devices running unskinned versions of Android are able to receive
updates from Google far faster than their skinned counterparts as Google
doesn't have to worry about tweaking the skin's custom code to work
with the update.
So the answer to which phone is best for you is determined largely by
the wider ecosystem in which you, or your office, are already embedded.
For users embedded in Mac OS, or with existing purchases from iTunes
and the App Store, the iPhone 6 Plus will be easier to set up and use.
This is particularly true with iOS 8, which is full of iCloud and Mac OS
X Yosemite synchronisation services.
For example, as well as letting you sync data, files and even open
web pages between iOS and Mac OS X devices, the Continuity upgrade means
you can answer calls and send texts from the iPhone using a Mac, so
long as both are running the latest software versions.
For those embedded in Google's ecosystem, the Nexus 6 features its own set of advanced synchronisation features.
The handset can be instructed to mirror the settings and application
portfolio of one of the user's older Android devices, making it equally
easy to set up a new device and get all the same apps and settings.
Additionally, the inclusion of key applications such as Google Docs
and Drive mean that users can synchronise the Nexus with their PC and do
things like edit documents started on the PC using the smartphone.
Winner: Tie
Security
While 2014 was rife with reports of the
first iOS malware and attacks on Mac OS, Apple has traditionally had a
lead in the security space thanks to its closed management policy.
Looking to build on this from a hardware and software perspective,
Apple has loaded the iPhone 6 Plus and iOS 8.1 with a number of hardware
and software security services.
One of the biggest of these is the custom Touch ID fingerprint scanner debuted on the iPhone 5S.
The Touch ID sensor locks the iPhone 6 Plus to the owner's
fingerprint and allows certain processes, such as NFC payments or in-app
purchases, only when it has detected the fingerprint.
iOS 8 also comes with a number of software upgrades designed to improve its enterprise appeal.
Key additions include tighter password security, S/MIME features, VIP
threads, support for Exchange out-of-office replies and busy/free
notifications in the Calendar app.
Prior to Lollipop we'd have said that the wealth of security features in iOS makes it the clear winner in the security stakes.
However, things are a little closer to call as Google has made a
number of key upgrades that radically improve Android's native security.
Three of the most important are Lollipop's enhanced SELinux enforcing
mode, Smart Lock and the decision to turn Android's encryption powers
on by default.
The SELinux enforcing mode is an anti-malware feature that protects
the Nexus 6 from infection by continuously monitoring the phone and
installed apps for suspicious behaviour.
Smart Lock is a nifty service that can pair a 'trusted' Android Wear
watch with a Lollipop smartphone or tablet. Once linked, the feature
lets the Nexus 6 know when it's near its owner and offers an easy entry
mode that does not require physically logging in.
The encryption by default is a smart move by Google as it
automatically instructs the Nexus 6 to encrypt stored data and offers an
added layer of protection against physical and cyber threats such as
man-in-the-middle attacks.
While we have to tip our hat to Google for improving Android's
security - which means IT managers or users who know what they're doing
can make it every bit as safe as iOS - the fact is that iOS remains the
safer bet.
Thanks to Google's open management policy, Android is inherently more
prone to abuse and makes it easier for criminals to target with
malicious applications, a fact demonstrated by the ever increasing
number of malware families targeting Google's ecosystem.
Winner: iPhone 6 Plus